Brian Quintenz, a Kalshi director and former Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) commissioner, said insider trading may be easier to detect in prediction markets than in equities because contracts are tied directly to specific events. But the possibility of insider trading, he said, does not mean these markets should be prohibited. Exchanges need safeguards before trading begins, alongside enforcement when rules are broken, and regulators still have work to do in clarifying standards.
Quintenz spoke Thursday at a congressional crypto forum hosted by The Hill and The Block. He said insider-trading cases are far more common in equities than in derivatives or prediction markets. In prediction markets, however, it is often easier to see whether a trader could have influenced the event on which they placed a bet. The debate highlights a central regulatory challenge: allowing event-based contracts while limiting participation by people with privileged information or the ability to affect the outcome.
Former regulators call for clearer trading restrictions
Dan Berkovitz, vice chair of external and regulatory affairs at Millennium Management and a former CFTC commissioner, said federal law and exchange rules already prohibit insider trading. Exchanges should also spell out who cannot trade particular contracts, including employees of organizations involved in an event and anyone able to influence its outcome, he said. He called for participation limits and robust anti-manipulation provisions.
Berkovitz pointed to “mention markets,” where a contract’s outcome may depend on whether someone says a particular word or phrase. A person who can decide whether to say it may be able to influence settlement. He welcomed CFTC guidance on the issue but said regulators need to clarify further who has inside information and who can influence or control an outcome.
Christy Goldsmith Romero, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and a former CFTC commissioner, said exchanges are the first line of defense against insider trading, though the CFTC may need to do more. When exchanges self-certify contracts, they must determine that the products are not readily susceptible to manipulation. Romero said regulators should provide more specific standards to help exchanges meet that test.
Quintenz also backed additional guidance. Whether a contract is “not readily susceptible to manipulation” requires judgment, he said, and the CFTC should explain how to apply the standard rather than leaving each exchange to set its own threshold. Clearer criteria affect which contracts platforms can list and traders’ expectations that rules will be applied consistently.
Sports contracts raise questions over federal and state authority
Forum participants also debated who should regulate sports event contracts. Berkovitz said the final rules adopted after the Dodd-Frank Act continue to bar gaming contracts under CFTC rules unless the agency changes them. A recent interim rule, however, distinguishes gambling conducted in casinos from products listed on federally regulated exchanges. That leaves a legal question, he said: can substantially similar products be treated as swaps on one platform but not another?
Quintenz said he submitted a comment letter in his personal capacity. He argued that the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2018 sports-betting decision did not give states exclusive regulatory authority. In his view, federal agencies can regulate exchanges while states continue to oversee casinos and sports-betting operators.
Romero said conflicting rulings across federal appeals courts could prompt the Supreme Court to take up the dispute. She also said prediction markets could ultimately face an unfavorable outcome over sports contracts. As platforms introduce more contracts tied to public companies and their shares, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) may also become more involved, she added. Clearer guidance from the SEC and CFTC would help exchanges and market participants understand which rules apply.