Gold fell 8.9% last week to about $3,538 an ounce, returning to levels last seen in September 2025. The price is now more than a third below its record above $5,600 an ounce, set in January. Economist and longtime gold bull Peter Schiff sees similarities with the market around the 2008 financial crisis, when gold slid before bottoming and then rallied after the Federal Reserve cut rates sharply and bought assets. For now, traders are still assessing the possibility of another Fed rate hike on December 9, leaving the timing of any policy shift a key variable for gold.
Schiff draws a parallel with gold's 2008 downturn
In his weekly podcast, Schiff recalled that gold peaked in early 2008 and fell for several months. When stock markets crashed that autumn, gold dropped more sharply for a time. But, he noted, gold bottomed in late 2008, while the S&P 500 did not end its decline until March 2009.
Gold subsequently climbed from about $681 an ounce to around $1,921 in September 2011, a gain of roughly 183%. The rally followed the Fed cutting interest rates to near zero and injecting money into markets through asset purchases. Schiff's comparison highlights that a steep short-term decline does not necessarily mark a lasting reversal in gold's longer-term trend. But that historical rebound depended on the monetary policy conditions at the time and does not guarantee a similar move now.
Margin calls may add to selling pressure
Schiff attributed some of the recent selling to forced liquidations. Traders who borrow to take positions in gold futures may face margin calls when prices fall. They then have to provide more cash or sell holdings, potentially adding to downward pressure.
He also said large buyers, including central banks, were waiting for the sell-off to run its course. In the physical precious-metals market, Schiff cited online dealers selling silver coins at premiums of $10 to $15 over spot prices. No further details were provided about the coin types or the range of quotes, so the premiums cannot be taken as a measure of supply and demand across the wider silver market.
Schiff runs precious-metals dealer SchiffGold and discussed how gold and silver traders view the prospect of a crisis in the same podcast. He said traders may recognize that a crisis is approaching but misjudge the market consequences. Those remarks reflect his assessment of markets and policy; gold's recent performance continues to show pressure from expectations of higher interest rates.
Fed rate expectations shape the timing of a possible rebound
Schiff expects a Fed policy pivot—an end to rate increases followed by easing—to help drive gold's next advance. He has also warned that prolonged monetary tightening could hit stock and bond markets. Unlike in 2008, the immediate focus now is traders' bets on a rate hike on December 9 and when the expected path for interest rates might change.
Investors holding bullion, gold funds or mining shares have already seen the impact of gold's retreat from its record. Those using leverage in futures may also face margin calls that force sales during a decline. Schiff's historical comparison offers one interpretation of the pullback, but whether gold can rebound as it did after 2008 will depend on subsequent policy changes and whether selling pressure eases.