MSCI plans to remove Strategy from several indexes after the market close on Nov. 30, with the changes taking effect Dec. 1. Three BlackRock iShares funds reported combined holdings of 123,056 Strategy shares as of Nov. 13, worth about $13.74 million. The holdings are a snapshot from a specific date, not a confirmed estimate of shares the funds must sell: tracking methods differ, and an index change does not necessarily trigger a sale of the same size on the effective date.
MSCI US index changes take effect Dec. 1
The MSCI USA Index covers large- and mid-cap US companies, with constituents and weightings determined by the index provider’s rules. Strategy’s Class A shares are expected to be removed after the Nov. 30 close, with the change effective Dec. 1. The decision follows new eligibility rules for companies MSCI classifies as non-operating. Strategy is among the companies selected for removal. Results for other specialized index variants are expected on Nov. 18.
Index funds aim to track their benchmarks, but they are not all required to hold every constituent directly. The iShares MSCI USA ETF (MLRG), for example, uses representative sampling: its managers can hold a portfolio designed to track the index’s performance without matching every constituent exactly. The fund reported 5,227 Strategy shares, worth about $583,000, as of Nov. 13. Its filings say it generally invests most or nearly all of its assets in index constituents, broadly in line with their index weights, while allowing some non-index holdings to help track performance or prepare for expected changes. The disclosures do not require it to sell all 5,227 shares at the Nov. 30 close.
Three funds reported about $13.74 million in Strategy shares
The iShares MSCI World ETF (URTH), which covers developed-market companies including US firms, reported 29,345 Strategy shares worth about $3.3 million on Nov. 13. The iShares MSCI ACWI ETF (ACWI), which tracks companies in both developed and emerging markets, reported 88,484 shares worth about $9.9 million on the same date. Because both broader indexes include the US market, Strategy’s removal from the MSCI USA Index affects the US portion of their benchmarks.
Together with MLRG, the three funds held 123,056 shares worth about $13.74 million. URTH and ACWI also use representative sampling, giving managers some discretion in how they track their indexes. The figures cover only these three identified funds; they do not include every fund affected by MSCI’s changes and are not an estimate of future sales.
The iShares ESG Advanced MSCI USA ETF (USXF) separately reported 16,144 Strategy shares on Nov. 13. It tracks a version of the MSCI USA Index with additional screening criteria. As of Nov. 17, MSCI had not announced changes to the relevant specialized indexes, so the decision affecting the standard index does not yet determine how USXF will adjust its holdings.
Swap exposure does not reveal underlying stock holdings
BlackRock also manages the iShares MSCI USA Swap UCITS ETF, which trades in Europe under tickers including MUSD. Unlike a fund that directly holds index constituents, it owns a basket of developed-market stocks and uses total-return swaps with financial institutions to exchange the portfolio’s performance for the return of the MSCI USA Index.
Once Strategy leaves the index, it will no longer contribute to the index return. But public filings do not say whether MUSD’s separate stock portfolio holds Strategy or whether the fund will sell any shares. Swap counterparties may adjust their own positions to manage risk, but those transactions are not reported in the fund disclosures. MUSD’s assets under management multiplied by Strategy’s index weight therefore cannot be used to calculate a required number of shares to sell.
In a submission to MSCI, Strategy said funds tracking the provider’s global investable indexes held about 13 million Strategy shares in total, equivalent to 3.1% of its outstanding common stock. That figure covers more funds than the three listed above, but does not name them or specify the date on which the holdings were measured.
Changes in reported holdings will not establish why shares moved
Daily fund disclosures after the index change can be compared with pre-change holdings, but a decline in reported shares would not necessarily mean the fund sold the same number on the open market. ETF assets change with investor inflows and outflows. When a fund grows, holdings may rise with its assets; when it contracts, securities may also leave through the redemption process, with the underlying shares transferred to financial institutions that return ETF units.
Comparisons between dates therefore need to account for changes in each fund’s shares outstanding and assets. Even if a filing shows fewer Strategy shares, it may not reveal how those shares left the fund or what the receiving institution did next. For MUSD, stock holdings alone also do not show any hedging adjustments made by swap counterparties.
Strategy’s removal could reduce demand from index-tracking investors and affect the financing environment for a company that sells securities to fund bitcoin purchases. The index change itself, however, does not require Strategy to sell any bitcoin. Fund holdings, investor flows and counterparty activity remain separate factors when assessing actual market selling pressure.